Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. ", "A Mystery in Ben Carson's Ties With Supplement Maker Mannatech", "Carson to Newsmax: 'I Didn't Know Anything About all [Mannatech's] Legal Stuff. [117] In October 2013, Fox News hired Carson as a contributor to provide analysis and commentary across Fox News Channel's daytime and primetime programming, a relationship that lasted until the end of 2014. [201][202][203] He disclosed on November 20 that he subsequently became "extremely sick" and attributed his recovery to Regeneron's experimental antibody therapy. [64][65][66][67][68][69] Carson was accepted by Yale and offered a full scholarship covering tuition, room and board. big brother! Ben Carson was born on September 15, 1951 in Detroit, Michigan. The success of the procedure and the reconstructive techniques employed gained Carson world renown as a pediatric neurosurgeon. degree in psychology from Yale "with a fairly respectable grade point average although far from the top of the class". Carson has received numerous honors for his neurosurgery work, including more than 60 honorary doctorate degrees and numerous national merit citations. [10], Carson gained national fame among political conservatives after delivering a speech at the 2013 National Prayer Breakfast which was perceived as critical of the policies of President Barack Obama. "[176] Although it was reported that the position was for Secretary of Health and Human Services, Carson's business manager has disputed this, stating, "Dr. Carson was never offered a specific position, but everything was open to him. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. That's pretty much where the story of Carson's father at least as. In the 2015 volume A More Perfect Union: What We the People Can Do to Reclaim Our Constitutional Liberties (also written with his wife), he issued his interpretations of the mandate established by the U.S. Constitution. [174] Trump received the Republican nomination[174] and went on to be elected president on November 8, 2016. At 33, Ben Carson was named the youngest director of pediatric neurosurgery in the United States, most famous for separating the conjoined Binder twins, and performing the first successful brain surgery on a baby in the womb. [216], In 2021, Carson founded the American Cornerstone Institute or ACI, a conservative think tank centered around advancing policies that promote "faith, liberty, community, and life". [182] HUD saw an exodus of career officials during Carson's tenure. At the age of eight (8), Ben's parents had divorced and so he had to live with his mother and brother, spending a brief period in Boston, Massachusetts, US; where his maternal family resides, and then back to Detroit. [27][28] At the age of five, his mother learned that his father had a prior family and had not divorced his first wife. He grew up attending Detroit public school, and his mother worked multiple jobs to provide for him and his brother . Here's what you need to know. Dr. Ben Carson has an older brother named Curtis. [28][34] In 1965, at the age of 13, he moved with his mother and brother back to their house on Deacon Street. It is absolutely absurd to say I had any kind of relation with them. Carson has often shared that at times his academic performance lagged well behind his peers. She joined Britannica in 2006 and Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. [93] Although there were few follow-up stories following the Binder twins' return to Germany seven months after the operation,[93] both twins were reportedly "far from normal" two years after the procedure, with one in a vegetative state. He had been doing some fundraising for the hospital and some other chairs about that time, and he simply got things mixed up. Ben Carson and his brother were raised in inner-city Detroit, with their odds of becoming successful almost non-existent, yet Ben eventually became the head of the pediatric neurosurgery unit at Johns Hopkins, largely due to his mother's influence. He went on to say, "I hope by that time I'm not around anymore. [24][25][26] Carson was born in Detroit, Michigan, on September 18, 1951. Carson said the professor awarded him $10 and that a photographer for the Yale Daily News was present to take his picture, which appeared in the student newspaper with a story about the experiment. Dr. Ben Carson overcame obstacles with mom's help. [191][192] Carson's wife, son, and daughter-in-law also attended official meetings. [13] He said, "[T]his grassroots movement on behalf of 'We the People' will continue", indicating that he would give more details later in the week. [172], During the Republican National Convention, Carson appeared with former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani in support of the pro-Donald Trump Great America PAC at an event in Cleveland. "[212][213], In 1994, Carson and his wife started the Carson Scholars Fund that awards scholarships to students in grades 411 for "academic excellence and humanitarian qualities". 4.0 721 Reviews . But 27-year-old Karly Bailey isn't impressed with Ben Carson's achievements. [80] In November 2015, the Detroit Free Press republished an article from 1988 "to try to bring some clarity to the claims currently being brought into question". 'I'll Leave That Up to God', "Dr. Ben Carson will speak at CPAC after stealing spotlight from President Obama", "Dr. Ben Carson announces his retirement, hints at political future", "Cruz wins Values Voter Summit's 2016 straw poll", "Interviews with 1,045 adult Americans conducted by telephone by ORC International on November 21-23, 2014", "Outsider Ben Carson Rises in 2016 GOP Field", "Hillary holds steady against cloudy Republican field in Pennsylvania", "Ben Carson 2016 Presidential Announcement Coming Monday", "Dr. Ben Carson Accidentally Announces He's Running for President", "Ben Carson, conservative neurosurgeon, running for president", "Ben Carson to announce 2016 intentions in Detroit on May 4", "Ben Carson announces candidacy and says, 'I'm not a politician', "Small Business Donations a Bull's-Eye for Ben Carson Super PAC", "GOP race gets jolt of diversity with Ben Carson, Carly Fiorina", "Ben Carson soaring as GOP heads into new debates", "New questions emerge over Carson's personal history", "88 Free Press article helps clarify Ben Carson claims", "Ben Carson Releases Rap Ad on the Radio", "Ben Carson 'Horrified' By His Own Campaign Ad", "Ben Carson: I will make Isis 'look like losers' if elected president", "Ben Carson ends campaign, will lead Christian voter group", "Ben Carson Accepts That His Campaign Is Finished", "Ben Carson Suspects His Campaign Was a Scam", "Ben Carson's Endorsement Of Donald Trump Just Got Even Stranger", "Ben Carson backs Trump, saying combative billionaire has 'cerebral' side", "Ben Carson: Harriet Tubman Would Be 'Turning Over in Her Grave' If She Knew She Was on $20", "First Draft: Donald Trump Discusses How He'll Select a Running Mate", "Carson floats Cruz as attorney general to go after Clinton", "Ben Carson at odds with campaign over Trump considering Democratic VP", "Despite reports to the contrary, Ben Carson still advising Trump on possible VPs", "Ben Carson spilled the beans on Donald Trump's possible vice-presidential picks", "Ben Carson: Walter Cronkite was 'left-wing radical' but fair", "Donald Trump has been elected the 45th president of the United States", "Carson not interested in serving in Trump administration", "Trump nominated Carson to lead U.S. housing, urban policy", "Banking Committee approves Ben Carson nomination", "Roll Call Vote 115th Congress - 1st Session", "HUD embodies the pathologies afflicting the White House", "Under Ben Carson, HUD Scales Back Fair Housing Enforcement", "Biden's First Task at Housing Agency: Rebuilding Trump-Depleted Ranks", "Carson: 'There were other immigrants who came in the bottom of slave ships, who worked even longer, even harder, for less', "Ben Carson told HUD staff he could zap their brains into reciting whole books read 60 years ago. [247][248], Carson is a member of the American Academy of Achievement,[249][250] Alpha Omega Alpha Honor Medical Society,[251] and the Horatio Alger Association of Distinguished Americans. [231][232] Carson was baptized at Burns Seventh-day Adventist Church in Detroit. [183], On March 6, his first day as secretary, while addressing Housing and Urban Development (HUD) employees, Carson saluted the work ethic of immigrants, and during his comments, he likened slaves to involuntary immigrants. Regarding the Middle East, he also claimed that "the Chinese are there". Yes. He polled 10% to Mitt Romney's 20%, but in the same poll with Romney removed from the list, Carson polled 11% to Jeb Bush's 14%. Ben Carson's operation to separate twins joined at the head was the first successful one . [36][37], By grade 9, the family's financial situation had improved, his mother surprising neighbors by paying cash to buy a new Chrysler car,[38] and the only government assistance they still relied on was food stamps. While Patrick remained in a vegetative state till he died, Benjamin does show some awareness, although he never learned to speak or sit up by himself, nor can he dress himself or feed himself. The 2023 Victoria's Voice Foundation 200 at Las Vegas Motor Speedway was filled with a ton of action. [70][71] In 1973, Carson graduated with a B.A. [197], On March 1, 2020, the office of Vice President Mike Pence announced Carson's addition to the White House Coronavirus Task Force. [199][200] He initially treated himself with a homeopathic oleander extract on the recommendation of Mike Lindell, the founder of My Pillow, Inc., which Carson said caused his symptoms to disappear. As of 2023, Ben Carson's net worth currently stands at $35 million. After explaining the risk, and despite that fact, Ben agrees to operate. [83][84] He continued with a regular academic load, and his grades improved to average in his first year of medical school. [233] Although Carson is an Adventist, the church has officially cautioned church employees to remain politically neutral. [156], Carson said he is not opposed to a Palestinian state, but he questioned why it needs "to be within the confines of Israeli territory Is that necessary, or can you sort of slip that area down into Egypt? [29][30] In Boston, Carson's mother attempted suicide, had several psychiatric hospitalizations for depression, and for the first time began working outside the home as a domestic worker,[29] while Carson and his brother attended a two-classroom school at the Berea Seventh-day Adventist church where two teachers taught eight grades, and the vast majority of time was spent singing songs and playing games. [86] He then spent one year (19831984) as a Senior Registrar in neurosurgery at the Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital in Nedlands, a suburb of Perth, Western Australia. Almost as important is that Carson has become a role model for people of all ages, especially children. [5] In 1987, he gained significant fame after leading a team of surgeons in the first known separation of conjoined twins joined at the back of the head. American neurosurgeon and politician (born 1951). And why would he torment somebody forever who only had a life of 60 or 70 or 80 years? [209][210][211], Carson was accused by members of the Department of Housing and Urban Development of making transphobic remarks at a meeting in San Francisco in September 2019. However, soon thereafter his campaign began to struggle when questions mounted concerning his grasp of foreign policy. [115], On November 3, 2015, Mannatech said on its website that for compliance with federal campaign finance regulations, the company had removed all references to Carson before he announced his bid for the presidency. In an effort to promote self-sufficiency, Carson supported rent increases for those receiving federal housing assistance or living in public housing properties. [240] Some Adventists have argued that Carson's political positions on gun rights and religious liberty conflict with historic Adventist teachings in favor of nonviolence, pacifism, and the separation of church and state. Benjamin Solomon Carson Sr. (born September 18, 1951) is an American retired neurosurgeon and politician who served as the 17th United States Secretary of Housing and Urban Development from 2017 to 2021. [40] Carson served as a laboratory assistant in the high school's biology, chemistry, and physics school laboratories beginning in grades 10, 11, and 12, respectively,[45] and worked as a biology laboratory assistant at Wayne State University the summer between grade 11 and 12. [185], Under the federal budget proposed by Trump in 2017, HUD's budget for the fiscal year 2018 would be cut by $6.2 billion (13%) and the Community Development Block Grant, a program which Carson praised in a trip to Detroit as HUD secretary, would be eliminated. [139][140], On May 2, 2015, Carson proclaimed that in two days he was going to make a major announcement on his decision on whether to enter the presidential race. [135][136], On November 4, 2014, the day of the 2014 midterms, he rejoined the Republican Party, saying it was "truly a pragmatic move" because he was considering running for president in 2016. He does say that his older brother, then a student at the University of Michigan, received a low number (26) in the first draft lottery in 1969 and was able to enlist in the Navy for four years instead of being drafted,[74] whereas he received a high number (333) in the second draft lottery in 1970. "[77], In the summers following his high school graduation until his second year in medical school, Carson worked at a variety of jobs: as a clerk in the payroll office of Ford Motor Company, supervisor of a six-person crew picking up trash along the highway under a federal jobs program for inner-city students, a clerk in the mailroom of Young & Rubicam Advertising, assembling fender parts and inspecting back window louvers on the assembly line at Chrysler, a crane operator at Sennett Steel, and finally a radiology technician taking X-rays. [159][160][161], On March 11, 2016, a week after Carson ended his presidential campaign, he endorsed Trump, calling him part of "the voice of the people to be heard". He said that President Trump had given him access to the drug. Internal documents obtained by The Washington Post under the Freedom of Information Act showed that the younger Carson "put people he'd invited in touch with his father's deputies, joined agency staff on official conference calls about the listening tour and copied his wife on related email exchanges". Sonya moved her sons to Boston where she lived with her sister for a short time. The separation surgery held promise in part because the twin boys had separate brains. In the 2014 cycle, Williams made $95,700, according to records. I don't want to sit here and say all of his policies are bad. [163] Such moves were met with opposition, as critics alleged that he failed to understand the complexities of the issues. Created By Olivia Brown. I didn't have any involvement with Mannatech. [12] He withdrew from the race after Super Tuesday, following a string of disappointing primary results, and endorsed Donald Trump. How many times has Dr ben Carson been married? Articles from Britannica Encyclopedias for elementary and high school students. [119], In financial disclosure forms, Carson and his wife reported income of between $8.9 million and $27 million from January 2014 to May 3, 2015, when he announced his presidential campaign. [253] Detroit Public Schools opened the Dr. Benjamin Carson High School of Science and Medicine[254] for students interested in pursuing healthcare careers. [59][41][60][61] He wanted to attend college farther away than his brother who was at the University of Michigan. Among them are claims of him hitting his friend with a pad-lock over the head, stubbing his friend in the stomach with a knife and trying to hit his mother over the head with a hammer and his brother stopping him. [93][94][95][96] Neither twin was ever able to talk or care for himself, and both eventually became institutionalized wards of the state. [154], The New York Times reported in 2015, "Carson has acknowledged being something of a novice on foreign affairs." The long tradition of black conservatism", "5 Things You Should Know About Ben Carson", "Carson, Hopkins Colleagues Named to Institute of Medicine | Children's Hospital at Johns Hopkins | Baltimore, Maryland", "Sonya Carson, Ben Carson's Mother, Passes at 88", "Carson's positions on poverty create tension with rags-to-riches life story", "Ben Carson did not grow up living in public housing", "The Detroit childhood that shaped Ben Carson", "For Ben Carson, bleak memories of his time in Boston. "[245] To avoid causing others discomfort, he is willing to occasionally eat chicken or turkey, although he finds eating pork highly unpleasant. The Wall Street Journal confirmed the riot but could not find anyone who remembered Carson sheltering white students. [222] In 1981 Carson's wife became pregnant with twins before miscarrying in the fifth month of her pregnancy. [56] Media challenges to a number of Carson's statements included allegations of discrepancies between documented facts and certain assertions in his autobiography Gifted Handsallegations dismissed by Carson as a media "witch hunt". 'Transgendered' is considered a derogatory and offensive term for trans individuals. [88] As a surgeon, he specialized in traumatic brain injuries, brain and spinal cord tumors, achondroplasia, neurological and congenital disorders, craniosynostosis, epilepsy, and trigeminal neuralgia. . He doesn't have a sister, only an older brother named Curtis. This is fully in line with Adventist teaching, which promotes annihilationism. [191] The son's involvement prompted HUD staff to express concern; the department's deputy general counsel for operations wrote in a memorandum "that this gave the appearance that the Secretary may be using his position for his son's private gain". . (Trice Edney Wire) - When neurosurgeon Dr. Ben Carson started flirting for a Presidential run, I thought he had lost his mind. He has denied being paid by Mannatech to do anything else, saying he has been a "prolific speaker" who has addressed many groups. Ben and his older brother, Curtis, moved with their mother to live in Boston after learning that their father had a family and hadn't divorced his first wife. [190], In summer 2017, Carson allowed his son, Baltimore businessman, Ben Carson Jr., to participate in organizing a HUD "listening tour" in Baltimore. There was six cautions in the first two stages. [16] In 2001, he was named by CNN and Time magazine as one of the nation's 20 foremost physicians and scientists and was selected by the Library of Congress as one of 89 "Living Legends" on its 200th anniversary. The only jurisdiction he carried in the primaries was in the Alaska caucuses in which he won a single state house district, but this did not result in any delegates for his campaign from Alaska since the required threshold of votes statewide was not met. [20] Carson's mother was 13 and his father was 28 when they married, and after his father finished his military service, they moved from Chattanooga, Tennessee, to Detroit,[20][21] where they lived in a large house in the Indian Village neighborhood. While in his initial years of school, Carson was an average student. He married his wife, professional violinist Candy Carson, in 1975, and Ben Carson had three sons with her: Rhoeyce, Ben, Jr., and Murray. [48][49][50] Carson said the intended victim, whose identity he wants to protect, was a classmate, a friend, or a close relative. In 2012 Carson published America the Beautiful: Rediscovering What Made This Nation Great (cowritten with his wife), a work reflecting his growing interest in politics. We are seeing everything from doctors' offices and folks in the healthcare profession to motorcycle repair shops and bed and breakfasts. His parents divorced when he was eight years old, and thereafter he lived with his mother and brother, spending a brief period in Boston and later returning to Detroit. [229][230], Carson and his wife are members of the Seventh-day Adventist Church (SDA). In October 2015, Carson's campaign team said that "there was no contribution from Mannatech to Johns Hopkins" and that his statement had been "a legitimate mistake on his part. He tied for seventh place in the Washington Times/CPAC 2013 Straw Poll with 4% of the 3,000 ballots cast. [221] Together, the couple have three sons (Rhoeyce, Benjamin Jr., and Murray), as well as several grandchildren. [198], On November 9, 2020, Carson tested positive for COVID-19 after attending President Trump's Election Night party. [125], In January 2015, The Weekly Standard reported that the Draft Carson Committee had raised $13 million by the end of 2014, shortly after Carson performed well in a CNN/ORC poll of potential candidates in December 2014, coming second in two different versions. In addition, his debate performances were criticized for a perceived lack of energy. Summary Ben and his older brother Curtis grew up in a poverty stricken Detroit.When he was only eight years old, his father left their family, forcing his mother Sonya to aise them on her oourm Despite her low level education their mother is very intelligent and determined. At the age of five, Carson's mother Sonya found out that his father had a prior wife whom he did not divorce. Although Carson showed potential as a student, he performed poorly in school until his mother challenged him and his brother with reading and writing assignments in addition to their regular schoolwork. He was a vocal supporter of eventual winner Donald Trump, who in December 2016 announced that he would nominate Carson to serve as secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development. In 1994 Carson cofounded the Carson Scholars Fund, an organization that awarded scholarships to students who had demonstrated academic excellence and community service. October 5, 2015. 1. [57] Carson, while acknowledging the class number was not correct, said: "You know, when you write a book with a co-writer and you say that there was a class, a lot of [the] time they'll put a number or something just to give it more meat. The movie took its title from Carsons autobiography, Gifted Hands (1990; with Cecil Murphey). Dr. Carson believes he might be able to successfully separate them, but realizes that he also risks losing one or both of them. [118], In 2014, some House Republicans (who later formed the House Freedom Caucus) approached Carson about the possibility of his standing for Speaker of the House in the event that the incumbent Speaker, John Boehner, had to step down because of intraparty disunion. Carson developed a newfound interest in learning and eventually earned a scholarship to Yale University, receiving a bachelors degree in psychology in 1973. [19] Robert Carson was a Baptist minister, but he later became a Cadillac automobile plant laborer. Later, she returned to Detroit and worked as many as three jobs at a time to support herself and her boys. [132][133] In the 2014 CPAC straw poll, he was in third place with 9% of the vote, behind senators Ted Cruz of Texas (with 11%) and Rand Paul of Kentucky (31%). [116], In July 2013, Carson was hired by The Washington Times as a weekly opinion columnist. "I just saw so much hypocrisy in both parties", he said. [80][Note 1] Carson also said the University of Michigan had offered him a scholarship. If they want to criticize the fact that I believe in a literal, six-day creation, let's have at it because I will poke all kinds of holes in what they believe. Now that he has jumped into the fray, opening his mouth one too many times, I know he has. On doing so, Carson said he was congratulated by the course instructor, who told him the retest was a hoax intended to find "the most honest student in the class". Omissions? [195][196] In response, Carson went on the Fox Business Network where he accused Democrats of adhering to "Saul Alinsky" tactics. Earlier, he had said he was unaware of the company's legal history. [29] In 1959, at the age of eight, his parents separated and he moved with his mother and brother to live for two years with his mother's Seventh-day Adventist older sister and her sister's husband in multi-family dwellings in the Dorchester and Roxbury neighborhoods of Boston. Recently a number of questions were raised about the claims made by Ben Carson. [236], Carson has stated that he does not believe in hell as understood by some Christians: "You know, I see God as a very loving individual. [152] They spent $150,000 on the ads, which were aired in Atlanta, Detroit and Miami. Neurosurgeon, medical director, foundation executive and author Dr. Benjamin Solomon Carson, Sr. was born on September 18, 1951 in Detroit Michigan, to Sonya and Robert Solomon Carson. "[152] Later, he said the advertisement was done without his knowledge, that "it was done by people who have no concept of the black community and what they were doing", and that he was "horrified" by it. Ben Carson is one of the most famous and respected doctors in the world. He warned that "big, hairy men" might infiltrate homeless shelters for women, prompting one woman to walk out. Joins Galectin Therapeutics as Special Consultant to Accelerate and Enhance Development of Company's Galectin-3 Inhibitor, Belapectin", "A Candid Interview With Dr. Ben S. Carson, M.D. [214], Recipients of the Carson Scholars Fund receive a $1,000 scholarship towards their college education. Carson questioned whether his campaign was economically sabotaged from within. Both Carson and his brother experienced difficulty in . It is soon later that he meets Lacena Rustin (Candy). He later also held professorships in plastic surgery, oncology, and pediatrics at Johns Hopkins. [129] The speech garnered Carson considerable attention because the event is normally apolitical in nature, and the speech was critical of the philosophy and policies of President Barack Obama, who was sitting 10 feet away. [27], In 1961, at the age of 10, he moved with his mother and brother back to southwest Detroit, where they lived in a multi-family dwelling in a primarily white neighborhood, (Springwells Village), across the railroad tracks from the Delray neighborhood, while renting out their house on Deacon Street, which his mother received in a divorce settlement. [97], According to The Washington Post, the Binder surgery "launched the stardom" of Carson, who "walked out of the operating room that day into a spotlight that has never dimmed", beginning with a press conference that was covered worldwide and created name recognition leading to publishing deals and a motivational speaking career. 1. He was born on Sept. 18, 1951. [93] Two sets of twins died, including Iranian twins Ladan and Laleh Bijani. [205] This expenditure was discovered after Helen Foster, a career HUD official, filed a complaint alleging that she had been demoted from her position because she refused to spend more than the legal $5,000 limit for office redecorations. The first book was an autobiography published in 1992. [168] On May 6, Carson said in an interview that Trump would consider a Democrat as his running mate, conflicting with Trump's assertion that he would not. [41][63] He said he decided to apply to Yale after seeing a team from Yale defeat a team from Harvard on the G.E. [224][225], After being diagnosed with prostate cancer, Carson underwent a two-hour operation at the Johns Hopkins Hospital on August 7, 2002. Today it might seem impossible to imagine that this brilliant neurosurgeon was once a poor student in school. Ben Carson, who was already a famous neurosurgeon, did not attend his father's funeral in 1992, according to the step-sister. Carson was said by aide Armstrong Williams in a May 10 interview to have withdrawn from the Trump campaign's vetting team, though the campaign confirmed he was still involved. With his conservative agenda, Carson initially proved popular with Republican voters, and by October 2015 he was among the partys front-runners. ", "Ben Carson leaves Costco board after declaring run for president", "Dr. Ben Carson named chairman of Frederick biotech Vaccinogen", "Vaccinogen Names Co-Founder and CEO Andrew L. Tussing as Chairman of the Board", "Vaccinogen Names Dr. Benjamin Carson and Dr. Jan B. Vermorken to Medical Advisory Board", "Ben Carson officially switches political parties, rejoins GOP", "Zondervan Author Ben Carson Gives Keynote at 2013 National Prayer Breakfast", "Dr. Ben Carson for President? [106][107] The nature of this relationship became an issue in 2015 during Carson's presidential campaign. *: These candidates were constitutionally ineligible to serve as President or Vice President. [245][246] Speaking in 1990, he said that with the increasing availability of meat substitutes, "It might take 20 years. 2. [99] His retirement became official on July 1, 2013. By Thomas Sowell. [186], In April 2017, while speaking in Washington at the National Low Income Housing Coalition conference, Carson said that housing funding would be included in an upcoming infrastructure bill from the Trump administration. Some have suggested that his brother, Curtis Carson, would be a logical . Ben Carson was born into poverty in Detroit and raised by a single mother. He could have been offered a scholarship by a private donor if he applied for admission and attended. His brother Benjamin is still alive and living in a nursing home in Germany. At an event last Friday in Arkansas, Carson was asked about his shifting.